1. Introduction: are we making better lawyers or merely faster draftsmen?

The legal profession is experiencing a transformation that may ultimately redefine the way lawyers research, reason, draft and deliver professional services. Artificial Intelligence, once regarded as a distant technological possibility, has become an increasingly accessible instrument in the everyday practice of law.

Today, a lawyer can generate a draft legal opinion, prepare a contract, summarise a judgment, examine statutory provisions and develop arguments for litigation within minutes. Tasks that once demanded hours, sometimes days, of research and intellectual engagement can now be undertaken with remarkable speed.

It is difficult to deny the attraction of this development. It would also be unwise for any legal practitioner to dismiss the opportunities it presents. The lawyer who refuses to understand and appropriately deploy emerging technology may gradually find himself disadvantaged in an increasingly competitive profession.

But beneath the excitement lies a question that deserves serious consideration:

Are we making better lawyers, or are we merely producing faster draftsmen?

More importantly, what happens to the young lawyer whose intellectual development depends on reading, researching, questioning, making mistakes, correcting those mistakes and gradually acquiring the confidence to defend an independent legal position?

If Artificial Intelligence begins to undertake these intellectual exercises on his behalf, where is the individual lawyer in all of this? Is he becoming more knowledgeable, or merely becoming more efficient at obtaining answers generated by a machine?

Perhaps the lawyer is still present, but his independent intellectual faculties are gradually being surrendered to the brain of a machine.

This is not an argument against Artificial Intelligence. Neither is it an attempt to resist the inevitable evolution of legal practice. It is, rather, a caution against allowing technological convenience to undermine the intellectual discipline upon which the legal profession is built.

The real challenge is not whether young lawyers should use Artificial Intelligence. They should. The more important question is how they can benefit from it without surrendering the very qualities that make them lawyers.

2. The beauty and the dangerous abyss of Artificial Intelligence in legal drafting

There is no denying the remarkable advantages of Artificial Intelligence in legal drafting.

A young lawyer preparing a statement of claim, an affidavit, a written address or a legal opinion can use AI to organise his thoughts, improve the structure of his arguments, identify possible weaknesses and express his submissions with greater clarity.

It can assist in locating relevant legal principles, summarising lengthy judgments, comparing statutory provisions and suggesting alternative approaches to a legal problem.

These are valuable contributions. For a young lawyer still developing his drafting skills, AI can serve as a useful learning companion. It can expose him to different styles of legal writing and demonstrate how arguments may be presented with greater precision and coherence.

But there is a dangerous side to this convenience.

A lawyer may become so dependent on the machine that he gradually loses the appetite to think independently. Instead of wrestling with a legal issue, he simply submits a prompt. Instead of examining the authorities, he accepts the authorities supplied by the machine. Instead of constructing an argument, he asks AI to construct one for him.

The resulting document may look impressive. Its grammar may be excellent, its paragraphs well arranged and its language sufficiently sophisticated to impress an unsuspecting reader.

Yet, beneath that impressive presentation, there may be very little independent legal reasoning.

This is where the danger lies.

Legal drafting is not simply an exercise in arranging words. It is the intellectual process of identifying a legal problem, understanding the material facts, discovering the applicable law, examining the authorities and constructing a persuasive argument.

A beautifully drafted document does not necessarily represent a beautifully reasoned mind.

A machine may produce a document that resembles the work of an experienced lawyer. But can it give a young lawyer the professional judgment, intellectual maturity and practical wisdom that ordinarily emerge from years of legal engagement?

There is a fundamental difference between possessing a well-drafted document and possessing the knowledge required to defend every proposition contained in it.

A lawyer who cannot explain the reasoning behind his own written address is not strengthened by the elegance of its language.

A borrowed mind may produce an impressive document, but it cannot independently develop the intellectual character of its owner.

3. The intellectual struggle that makes a lawyer

One of the most important aspects of becoming a lawyer is the intellectual struggle involved in acquiring knowledge.

The young lawyer must learn to read beyond the immediate issue, examine conflicting authorities, understand judicial reasoning and appreciate why one argument succeeds while another fails.

This process is not always comfortable. Sometimes the law appears confusing. Sometimes two decisions seem to point in different directions. Sometimes an apparently straightforward legal issue becomes complicated after closer examination.

But it is through this intellectual struggle that the lawyer develops.

Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr., in The Common Law (1881), made the memorable observation:

“The life of the law has not been logic: it has been experience.”

This observation is particularly relevant in the age of Artificial Intelligence. The practice of law is not sustained by logical arrangement alone. It is shaped by human experience, the interpretation of facts, professional judgment, social realities and the practical consequences of legal decisions.

A young lawyer must therefore experience the process of legal reasoning for himself.

He must learn to question an authority, distinguish a case, challenge an argument and, where necessary, disagree with an apparently settled position.

Francis Bacon, in his essay Of Studies, also observed:

“Reading maketh a full man; conference a ready man; and writing an exact man.”

There is a profound lesson in this statement. Reading develops knowledge. Discussion sharpens understanding. Writing disciplines the mind and compels the individual to express his thoughts with precision.

These are not activities that should be surrendered entirely to a machine.

Indeed, one of the greatest dangers of excessive dependence on AI is that a young lawyer may become familiar with answers without understanding the intellectual journey that produced them.

He may know what to say without knowing why he is saying it. He may possess a document without possessing the reasoning behind it.

The legal profession must not create a generation of practitioners who can generate impressive documents but struggle to defend the arguments contained in them.

The development of a lawyer’s mind is not an inconvenience to be eliminated. It is the foundation of professional competence.

4. How should the young lawyer use Artificial Intelligence?

The answer is not to avoid Artificial Intelligence. The answer is to use it intelligently and with professional discipline.

I would suggest a simple principle:

Think first. Research independently. Then invite AI into the process.

Before asking AI to prepare a legal document, the young lawyer should first understand the brief. He should identify the material facts, determine the legal issues, consider the applicable statutory provisions and authorities, and form an initial view of the position he intends to advance.

Only after this independent exercise should he turn to AI.

At that stage, AI can be used to test his argument, identify possible weaknesses, suggest alternative interpretations and improve the organisation and presentation of the draft.

It should be treated as an intellectual sparring partner, not an intellectual replacement.

I have personally engaged Artificial Intelligence in a legal reasoning exercise that continued over several days. I challenged its conclusions, questioned its interpretation and insisted on examining the reasoning behind its answers. The exchange became an exercise in testing arguments, examining authorities and challenging assumptions. At a point, the system acknowledged that its earlier position required correction.

That experience reinforced an important lesson: AI should never be approached as an unquestionable authority.

The young lawyer must be prepared to challenge it.

Make AI your court adversary even before you enter the courtroom.

  • Ask it to identify the weaknesses in your argument.
  • Ask it to construct the strongest opposing case.
  • Ask it to identify statutory provisions or judicial authorities that may undermine your position.
  • Ask it to explain why your argument may fail.

But do not stop there. Verify the authorities independently. Read the judgments. Examine the statutory provisions. Confirm that the cases exist and that the propositions attributed to them are accurate.

A lawyer must never confuse a confident answer with a correct answer.

AI can assist with legal reasoning, but it does not relieve the lawyer of the obligation to exercise independent judgment.

5. The need to question and verify what Artificial Intelligence produces

One of the most important professional responsibilities in the use of AI is verification.

Artificial Intelligence can produce information that appears authoritative but is inaccurate. It may cite a case that does not exist, misrepresent a judicial decision, quote a statutory provision incorrectly or apply a legal principle outside its proper context.

The danger is particularly serious in legal practice because reliance on a false authority can damage a client’s case and undermine the lawyer’s professional credibility.

A lawyer must therefore approach AI-generated legal content with disciplined scepticism.

  • Every authority must be verified.
  • Every quotation must be checked.
  • Every statutory provision must be read in its proper context.
  • Every legal proposition must be tested against the facts of the particular matter.

There is also the question of confidentiality and data protection. Client information should not be carelessly entered into AI systems without considering the confidentiality obligations owed to the client, the security of the platform and the applicable data protection requirements.

Professional responsibility cannot be outsourced.

The American Bar Association’s Model Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 1.1, Comment 8, recognises the importance of lawyers keeping abreast of changes in law and practice, including the benefits and risks associated with relevant technology.

Similarly, the ABA’s Formal Opinion 512 of 29 July 2024 addresses the professional obligations of lawyers using generative AI tools.

Although these American professional materials are not automatically binding on Nigerian legal practitioners, they offer useful guidance on the ethical and professional questions raised by technological advancement.

For Nigerian practitioners, the relevant obligations must also be considered in the light of the Rules of Professional Conduct for Legal Practitioners, applicable Nigerian laws, the Evidence Act 2011, as amended, and the Nigeria Data Protection Act 2023.

The central point remains that the lawyer is accountable for the work he presents, irrespective of the technology used in preparing it.

It is no defence to professional negligence or incompetence to say that the machine supplied the information.

The machine may have generated the draft, but the lawyer adopts it, signs it and presents it as professional work. The responsibility remains his.

6. What should senior lawyers do?

The responsibility does not rest exclusively on young lawyers.

Senior lawyers and practitioners who supervise younger colleagues must recognise that professional training involves much more than producing documents for immediate use.

A young lawyer should not simply be given an assignment, directed to obtain an AI-generated draft and instructed to submit it.

He should be encouraged to research the issue independently, prepare his own first draft and explain the reasoning behind his conclusions.

The senior lawyer can then introduce AI as a tool for testing, improving and challenging the work.

This approach preserves the traditional value of mentorship while preparing young lawyers for the realities of modern legal practice.

Senior lawyers must also be willing to learn. It would be a mistake to assume that professional experience alone makes one immune to technological change.

The profession should encourage a healthy exchange between experience and innovation.

The senior lawyer brings judgment, professional experience and practical wisdom. The younger lawyer may bring technological familiarity, fresh perspectives and new methods of research.

Both have something to contribute.

There is a natural process by which knowledge flows from experienced practitioners to younger colleagues. It resembles the nourishment a mother gives her child: the child grows stronger through what it receives, but must eventually develop the capacity to stand independently.

The objective of mentorship is not to produce lawyers who remain permanently dependent on their seniors. It is to develop practitioners who can think, reason, decide and act responsibly on their own.

Artificial Intelligence should be incorporated into this process, not allowed to displace it.

7. The future: the lawyer who knows how to think and use technology

The future of legal practice will almost certainly belong to lawyers who understand both the law and the technology that supports its administration.

It is no longer sufficient to be an excellent legal researcher while remaining completely unfamiliar with technological developments. Equally, technological proficiency without sound legal judgment is an inadequate foundation for professional practice.

The lawyer of the future must possess both.

He must know when AI can save time, when it can improve the quality of a document and when its output should be rejected.

He must understand that technology is an instrument of professional efficiency, not a substitute for professional responsibility.

There will always be legal questions that demand human judgment. There will always be clients whose circumstances cannot be properly understood through automated responses alone. There will always be disputes in which the interpretation of facts, the credibility of witnesses, the consequences of a decision and the demands of justice require a human mind.

The lawyer must therefore remain intellectually present in every matter he handles.

He must not become a professional zombie, mechanically presenting documents whose reasoning he has neither developed nor properly examined.

The joy of practising law lies not merely in obtaining a favourable result. It also lies in the intellectual journey of understanding a difficult issue, constructing a persuasive argument and standing before a court to defend a position with conviction.

That experience must not be lost.

The profession should embrace technological advancement without sacrificing the intellectual independence that gives legal practice its character and dignity.

8. Conclusion: do not allow the machine to become the lawyer

Artificial Intelligence is here, and it is not going away. Its contribution to legal practice will continue to grow. It would be neither sensible nor progressive to discourage young lawyers from exploring its capabilities.

But we must be careful about what we are encouraging.

We should encourage young lawyers to become more efficient, not intellectually dependent; more technologically informed, not less thoughtful; more productive, not less capable of independent reasoning.

The real measure of a lawyer is not the speed with which he produces a document. It is the quality of his understanding, the strength of his reasoning, his ability to interpret the law and his capacity to defend the position he has taken.

Let AI be the sparring partner of the young lawyer, not the custodian of his intellect. Let it challenge his arguments, expose his weaknesses and sharpen his reasoning. But never allow it to become the source of every thought he claims as his own.

A young lawyer must still read, question, reason, disagree, write and defend. He must experience the difficulty of learning because that difficulty is part of what makes him a competent legal practitioner.

We must embrace the future of legal practice, but we must not lose the mind of the promising advocate in the process.

Let the machine assist the lawyer, but never allow the lawyer to become an extension of the machine.


References

  • Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr., The Common Law (1881), Lecture I, p. 1.
  • Francis Bacon, Essays, Essay I, “Of Studies” (1597).
  • American Bar Association, Model Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 1.1, Comment 8.
  • American Bar Association, Formal Opinion 512: Generative Artificial Intelligence Tools (29 July 2024).
  • Rules of Professional Conduct for Legal Practitioners, Nigeria.
  • Evidence Act 2011 (as amended), Federal Republic of Nigeria.
  • Nigeria Data Protection Act 2023.

About the author.
Olu Bashorun, Esq.
Principal Partner

Email: olu.bash.law@gmail.com
Telephone: +234 802 590 3012 | +234 704 287 1925